Workplace Investigations

Common Types of Investigations

KBS Legal Solutions conducts workplace investigations across a broad range of issues. Each investigation requires careful handling, attention to detail, and a deep understanding of both legal requirements and internal policy standards.

Harassment and hostile work environment claims may take a variety of forms, such as:

  • Sexual harassment
  • Sexual assault or misconduct
  • Race-based harassment
  • Harassment based on national origin
  • Disability-based harassment
  • Age-based harassment
  • Retaliatory harassment

Bullying is typically defined by an organization’s internal policies and procedures. It includes verbal, written, or physical conduct that targets an individual or group, often in a demeaning or intimidating manner. Unlike illegal harassment, bullying does not need to be tied to a protected category to violate applicable policies.

Investigations often involve allegations of discrimination, including treating individuals differently based on a protected category (such as race, color, national origin, sex, gender, disability, religion, or age) and  failing to provide disability, religious, pregnancy, or breastfeeding-related accommodations.

Whistleblower retaliation occurs when an employer, manager, supervisor, or other individual in a position of authority takes a personnel action against an individual because they made protected disclosures.

Similar to discrimination claims, a common misconception is that an individual can only engage in whistleblower retaliation if that individual intended to retaliate. However, there is generally no intent requirement to substantiate a whistleblower retaliation claim. In other words, an individual or an entity can be found liable under federal, state, and local whistleblower retaliation laws even if they did not intend to retaliate. In fact, many substantiated cases of whistleblower retaliation occur when the individual or entity did not intend to retaliate or are unaware of the impact of their actions.

Examples include:

  • Terminating an employee within a few months of making a protected disclosure
  • Denying telework to an employee who made a protected disclosure while granting telework to similarly situated employees who did not make protected disclosures

Retaliation can also occur in non-whistleblower contexts. Retaliation occurs when an employer, supervisor, or other person in a position of authority takes an adverse or personnel action against an individual because they engaged in a protected activity, such as opposing harassing conduct, filing an EEO claim, or requesting a disability-related accommodation. As with whistleblower retaliation, intent is not required for liability.

Examples include:

  • Providing an employee with a poor performance evaluation shortly after the employee complained that they were subject to discrimination within the workplace.
  • Not selecting an employee for a promotion after they filed EEO complaints against their manager
  • Disciplining an employee who requested religious-based accommodations

Workplace investigations also address a wide range of misconduct, such as:

  • Senior leader misconduct
  • Abuse of authority
  • Lack of candor
  • Negligent supervision
  • Insubordination

The Importance of Neutral, Outside Investigations

Engaging an outside investigator delivers credibility, independence, and impartiality to your entity. When deciding whether to bring in external support, consider the following:

  • Will this matter lead to litigation?
  • Has your office received more than one prior complaint filed by the same individual or complainant?
  • Is the subject or respondent named in other complaints?
  • Does the complaint allege that your compliance office has a conflict of interest?
  • Does your compliance office have the capacity to investigate the complaint in a timely manner?
  • Does your compliance office have subject matter expertise or experience handling similar matters?

KBS Legal Solutions conducts thorough, legally sufficient investigations efficiently and effectively. We also offer expedited services to prioritize and streamline time-sensitive matters. KBS Legal Solutions recommends solutions to support systemic changes, prevent the compliance concern from recurring, and achieve compliance.

Investigation Process

KBS Legal Solutions conducts neutral, impartial, confidential, and legally sound investigations in a professional, expedient, and thorough manner. By utilizing a single-investigator model, KBS Legal Solutions offers investigation services from “soup to nuts,” handling every stage from intake to the final report.

KBS Legal Solutions also provides “second-review” investigations to evaluate whether a completed investigation is legally sufficient. In addition, KBS Legal Solutions crafts robust recommendations to address the underlying issues and allow for systemic changes.

Compliance with Federal and State Laws — and Beyond

KBS Legal Solutions’ investigations not only result in a legally-defensible report but also include actionable recommendations. These may involve management consulting, policy revisions, and process improvements to resolve compliance concerns and prevent future issues.

Working with HR and Leadership

KBS Legal Solutions collaborates closely and strategically with leadership teams and subject matter experts within each organization. This partnership ensures that investigations are aligned with internal processes and values while maintaining the independence and objectivity required for credibility.

Experience in Employment Settings

KBS Legal Solutions brings extensive experience in workplace investigations and employment law. Founder Kay Bhagat-Smith launched sensitive investigations and litigated employment cases as a former Investigative Counsel for two federal agencies, a former leader within a private, elite university, and a former litigator for a federal agency. Kay has resolved hundreds of complex employment disputes in educational, healthcare, law enforcement, and government settings.

Comprehensive “Soup to Nuts” Investigations

By utilizing the single-investigator model, KBS Legal Solutions conducts investigations from “soup to nuts,” by offering the following services:

  • Intake;
  • Scoping the allegations to ensure that any allegation opened for investigation states a violation of an applicable law and/or policy;
  • Developing a case plan;
  • Identifying and interviewing witnesses;
  • Requesting and reviewing applicable documents;
  • Conducting a thorough legal analysis; and
  • Drafting a legally sufficient and comprehensive report of investigation.

KBS Legal Solutions provides ongoing updates and recommendations throughout the life of an investigation.

Why KBS Legal Solutions

KBS Legal Solutions’ founder, Kay Bhagat-Smith, has the unique experience of investigating and resolving matters from three perspectives:

  • On behalf of individuals alleging harassment, discrimination, and/or misconduct;
  • As a neutral factfinding/decisionmaker; and
  • On behalf of the entity that is the subject of the investigation.

With almost two decades of experience investigating complex cases in a myriad of settings and from three perspectives, Kay is uniquely positioned to advise, investigate, mediate, and resolve complex allegations, complaints, and reviews.

Impartiality and Confidentiality

KBS Legal Solutions takes confidentiality seriously. KBS Legal Solutions’ founder and attorney Kay Bhagat-Smith previously held a top secret security clearance, where she handled highly sensitive information with professionalism and discretion throughout complex investigations.

KBS Legal Solutions safeguards sensitive information, including health care, educational, and personnel records. In conducting investigations, interfacing with human resources professionals, and updating leadership about the status of a sensitive matter, KBS Legal Solutions ensures that sensitive information is not unlawfully or inappropriately disseminated. KBS Legal Solutions takes care to balance transparency with the need for confidentiality. In communications, KBS Legal Solutions provides as much information as possible to allow for transparency, while safeguarding privileged and confidential information.