Civil Rights Investigations

There is no one-size-fits-all approach to each case, claim, or allegation. KBS Legal Solutions applies efficiency, customization, and excellence in framing the scope of the investigation. Depending on the number and complexity of issues, an investigation may include any or all of the following steps:

  • Framing the issue or allegation
  • Developing a case or investigative plan
  • Conducting investigative interviews
  • Gathering and reviewing documents, video footage, images, and cellphone and computer data
  • Reconciling conflicting evidence
  • Making credibility determinations
  • Conducting climate assessments
  • Charting numeric data
  • Conducting statistical analysis
  • Drafting comprehensive investigative reports

Federal and state laws also prohibit whistleblower reprisal and retaliation for making a protected disclosure or engaging in a protected activity, such as filing a discrimination complaint, participating in an investigation, or  requesting accommodations.

Applicable Laws

Federal, state, and local laws prohibit discrimination based on protected categories, including:

  • Disability
  • Race
  • National origin
  • Ethnicity
  • Color
  • Sex
  • Gender
  • Religion
  • Age
  • Marital status
  • Veteran status
  • Sexual orientation
  • Gender identity or expression
  • Personal appearance
  • Political affiliation
  • Genetic information

Applicable Laws Include

  • Title VI of the Civil Rights Act
  • Title VII of the Civil Rights Act
  • Title IX of the Education Amendments Act
  • Americans with Disabilities Act
  • Rehabilitation Act
  • Equal Pay Act
  • Age Discrimination in Employment Act
  • Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act
  • Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act
  • Providing Urgent Maternal Protections for Nursing Mothers Act
  • Whistleblower Protection Act
  • Civil Service Reform Act
  • D.C. Human Rights Act
  • Maryland State Code

Compliance with applicable federal, state, and local laws is the minimum requirement for achieving a healthy environment that is free from discrimination, harassment, and retaliation. Most entities maintain policies and procedures that go beyond their minimal legal obligations.

When determining whether your entity is in compliance with applicable laws and policies, it is essential that your compliance office can answer key questions, such as:

  • What are our obligations under applicable law?
  • What are our obligations under our policies and procedures?
  • Do our policies and procedures comply with the law in this changing landscape?
  • Are our employees and contractors aware of their responsibilities under these laws and policies?
  • What kind of training do our employees and contractors receive about their legal and policy-related responsibilities?
  • How do we monitor and track our compliance with laws and policies?
  • Where are there gaps in policy or legal compliance?
  • Which individuals or offices need additional training, support, or guidance to allow for compliance?
  • Have we reevaluated our policies and procedures after a compliance issue?
  • Are our policies and procedures confusing or conflicting?
  • Do we need to strengthen our policies and procedures?

Types of Institutions

KBS Legal Solutions conducts investigations for a wide range of institutions, including:

  • Educational institutions (universities, colleges, school districts, K-12 schools)
  • Federal agencies
  • State agencies
  • Companies
  • Prisons
  • Detention facilities
  • Healthcare facilities

Examples of Civil Rights Violations

Illegal discrimination occurs when an employee, student, third party, patient, detainee, or other individual is treated negatively because of a protected category. A common misconception is that an individual can only discriminate if they intend to do so. However, there is generally no intent requirement to substantiate a discrimination claim. Many substantiated discrimination cases occur when the individual or entity did not intend to discriminate or may not even be aware of the impact of their actions.

Examples of illegal discrimination include:

  • Hiring, disciplining, failing to promote, or terminating an employee based on a protected category
  • Assigning a student a low grade based on a protected category
  • Giving an employee a poor performance evaluation based on a protected category
  • Failing to accommodate an employee’s disability, religion, pregnancy, or breastfeeding needs

Failure to Provide Medical Treatment

The U.S. Constitution, and federal, state, and local law require federal and state agencies to provide medical treatment to individuals in their physical custody.

Examples of failure to provide medical treatment

  • Not providing individuals with diabetes with insulin treatment
  • Denying an inmate or detainee’s request for sign language interpretation and not providing equally effective alternatives for effective communication

Improper Use of Force, Restraint, and/or Seclusion

The U.S. Constitution and federal, state, and local law generally prohibit institutions from physically or chemically (i.e., involuntary administration of medication) restraining individuals (e.g., inmates, detainees, patients, and students) and/or placing individuals in seclusion unless there is an imminent threat to physical safety.

Generally, most laws and applicable policies require the institution to remove the individual from restraint and/or seclusion as soon as the emergency ends.

Not only do laws and policies restrict when a facility can restrain or place an individual in seclusion, but they also have stringent requirements about the manner in which the individual can be restrained.

Examples of improper use of force, restraint and/or seclusion

  • Placing a Marylander in a facedown (prone) restraint
  • Restraining a psychiatric patient because the patient did not follow a staff member’s directions.

Harassment is generally defined as unwelcome verbal, written, electronic, or physical conduct based on an individual’s actual or perceived protected category. When harassing conduct is severe or pervasive and denies or limits an individual’s access to the environment (whether in an employment, educational, healthcare, or correctional setting), it may create a hostile environment.

Examples of harassment include:

  • Unwelcome sexual advances
  • Sexual assault
  • Quid pro quo harassment
  • Sexual advances toward subordinate employees or students where a power imbalance exists
  • Racial or disability-based epithets

Though federal, state, and local laws generally require that harassing conduct must be related to an individual’s protected category, many organizations adopt internal policies that define harassment broadly and do not require that the conduct relates to a protected category. For example, an allegation that a supervisor repeatedly berated, demeaned, or intimidated employees may not implicate federal, state, or local anti-discrimination laws if the conduct was not related to an employee’s protected category. However, such conduct may be prohibited under the employer’s policies and procedures. 

Retaliation occurs when an employer, supervisor, professor, teacher, or other individual in a position of authority takes adverse action against an individual for engaging in a protected activity or making protected disclosures. Similar to discrimination claims, a common misconception is that an individual can only retaliate if that individual intended to retaliate. However, there is generally no intent requirement to substantiate a retaliation claim. In other words, an individual or an entity can be found liable for retaliation under federal, state, and/or local laws even if the individual or entity did not intend to retaliate. In fact, many substantiated cases of retaliation occur when the individual or entity did not intend to retaliate or the individual was unaware of the impact of their actions.

Federal, state, and local laws require entities to provide accommodations for:

  • Disabilities
  • Sincerely-held religious beliefs
  • Pregnancy needs
  • Breastfeeding needs

Accommodations

At a minimum, entities must ensure physical and virtual accessibility and engage in effective communication with individuals with disabilities. Generally, entities must also engage in an interactive process to determine appropriate accommodations, which are modifications that provide individuals with equal access to the entity’s programs and activities.

Examples of accommodations include:

Disability-related:

  • Flexible work schedule that permits an employee to work hours outside of the traditional workday
  • Additional telework flexibility
  • Ergonomic keyboard or standing desk
  • Additional breaks
  • Sign-language interpretation services

Breastfeeding-related:

  • Additional breaks that permit the individual to express breastmilk

Religion-related:

  • Flexible work schedule that permits an employee to not work during religious observances
  • Additional breaks that permit the individual to pray during the workday
  • Alternative dietary options in correctional, educational, or healthcare settings

Pregnancy-related:

  • Temporary changes to the location of an employee’s workstation
  • Additional telework

Accommodations are individualized. It is critical that the entity undergoes a legally sufficient interactive process in responding to a request for accommodations. To avoid liability, consider that it is the process, not the outcome, that matters the most. Your compliance office should consider the following:

  • What do our accommodation policies and procedures require?
  • Do our accommodation policies and procedures comply with applicable federal, local, and state law?
  • Who is the decision-maker?
  • Who must participate in the interactive process?
  • Is our process confidential?
  • Does our process permit us to share medical, pregnancy, and/or religious-based information within our entity?
  • Where do we maintain confidential medical records?
  • What are the bases for denying an accommodation?
  • When can we consider alternative accommodations?
  • Does our process permit us to provide interim accommodations during the interactive process?
  • How long are accommodations in effect?
  • When and how do we reevaluate accommodations?

Accessibility

Entities must ensure both physical and web-based accessibility to avoid civil rights violations.

Accessibility includes:

  • Physical accessibility
  • Web-based accessibility

Why KBS Legal Solutions

KBS Legal Solutions’ founder, Kay Bhagat-Smith, has the unique experience of investigating and resolving matters from three perspectives:

  • On behalf of individuals alleging harassment, discrimination, and/or misconduct;
  • As a neutral factfinding/decisionmaker; and
  • On behalf of the entity that is the subject of the investigation.

With almost two decades of experience investigating complex cases in a myriad of settings and from three perspectives, Kay is uniquely positioned to advise, investigate, mediate, and resolve complex allegations, complaints, and reviews.

Impartiality and Confidentiality

KBS Legal Solutions takes confidentiality seriously. KBS Legal Solutions’ founder and attorney Kay Bhagat-Smith previously held a top secret security clearance, where she handled highly sensitive information with professionalism and discretion throughout complex investigations.

KBS Legal Solutions safeguards sensitive information, including health care, educational, and personnel records. In conducting investigations, interfacing with human resources professionals, and updating leadership about the status of a sensitive matter, KBS Legal Solutions ensures that sensitive information is not unlawfully or inappropriately disseminated. KBS Legal Solutions takes care to balance transparency with the need for confidentiality. In communications, KBS Legal Solutions provides as much information as possible to allow for transparency, while safeguarding privileged and confidential information.

Comprehensive “Soup to Nuts” Investigations

By utilizing the single-investigator model, KBS Legal Solutions conducts investigations from “soup to nuts,” by offering the following services:

  • Intake;
  • Scoping the allegations to ensure that any allegation opened for investigation states a violation of an applicable law and/or policy;
  • Developing a case plan;
  • Identifying and interviewing witnesses;
  • Requesting and reviewing applicable documents;
  • Conducting a thorough legal analysis; and
  • Drafting a legally sufficient and comprehensive report of investigation.

KBS Legal Solutions provides ongoing updates and recommendations throughout the life of an investigation.

Contact KBS Legal Solutions
For Experienced Legal Advice & Investigative Services